« Exterminating White People | Main | Rove Not To Be Indicted; Libby Likely »
April 01, 2009
USA Today Caught 'Photoshop-ing'
It looks like yet another member of mainstream media has been caught 'Photoshop-ing.' Last week, USA Today doctored a photo of Condoleezza Rice, giving a demonic look about her. Michelle Malkin is keeping tabs on this story here and here.
USA Today has replaced the doctored photo, with the following explanation:
Editor's note: The photo of Condoleezza Rice that originally accompanied this story was altered in a manner that did not meet USA TODAY's editorial standards. The photo has been replaced by a properly adjusted copy. Photos published online are routinely cropped for size and adjusted for brightness and sharpness to optimize their appearance. In this case, after sharpening the photo for clarity, the editor brightened a portion of Rice's face, giving her eyes an unnatural appearance. This resulted in a distortion of the original not in keeping with our editorial standards.
I wasn't so sure it was simple brightening of a "portion of Rice's face;" any seasoned Photoshop user would agree. I decided to attempt to replicate USA Today's "brightening" to achieve similar results. The following screenshots and examples are from my efforts.
The USA Today doctored photo (Photo #1)

The original photo (Photo #2)

There was nothing to suggest that a general area around the eyes was brightened. Adjusting the contrast to the extreme showed no signs of doctoring outside the focused area of the eyes, with most differences likely attributed to existing JPEG compression, resulting in distortion and artifacts.

To emulate USA Today's doctoring, I had proceeded to focus on the eyes, and use the Lasso tool to draw a marquee around the specific area of the eyes.

I figured the next best way to only darken the darks, and lighten up the white of the eye was to adjust the curves.

From there, it still didn't quite look right, so I actually darkened the iris and around the eyes a bit, my end result is shown side by side with the other images, noted as photo #3 (click to enlarge).
As you can see, it was a concerted effort to add some white to the eyes with the act of "brightening" rather than specifically replacing pixels one-by-one (which when attempted, did not yield acceptable results). Using the Brightness tool, similar results were achieved, but only when brightening the white of her eyes only.
It seems pretty clear there was a specific intent to brighten the eyes, significantly altering the appearance of Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice. Nice try, USA Today, but I don't buy your excuse.
Posted by Aaron at April 1, 2009 12:00 AM
Copyright © 2007 by author. May not be copied, published, or otherwise used (except for brief quotes) without express permission of author. Articles published with permission by Pardon My English.
-->Comments
I'm guessing the portion of Rice's face they are referring to are her eyes.
Obviously, this photo shouldn't have been altered like it was or published like that.
Posted by Tom Shipley
at October 27, 2005 01:33 PM
Note: Comments once posted become the property of Pardon My English. We therefore reserve the right to make use of such in any manner and for whatever purpose we deem appropriate. Please refer to comment policy for further information.



